Difference between revisions of "Data Jamboree 2/Annotation Experiment"

From phenoscape
Line 1: Line 1:
== Curation consistency experiment: Review of Results ==
 
  
Character #2
 
* difference between depth, length, width
 
* some failed to post-compose (e.g., increased length)
 
* need to standardize shape, length, depth, and width definitions
 
* should then use higher level character (such as 'shape')
 
 
Character #3
 
* some use 'increased count' which is-a count
 
 
Character #4
 
* question of whether basihyal bone precludes presence (or implies absence) of cartilage
 
* question of how to annotate this looks more difficult than in reality is
 
* basihyal cartilage absent implies basihyal bone absent (because the latter develops from the former)
 
** in fact it can also be that the cartilage is absent b/c it has developed into the bone (completely ossified)
 
** hence need to add that basihyal is absent too
 
* graph view can be very helpful
 
 
Character #5
 
* software should prevent filling in relative entities for qualities that aren't relational
 
* post-composed relative entity because of uncertainty of whether the full (existing) term would be compatible with the definition the author may have been using (for a different clade)
 
* difficulty to find the 'bony projection' by auto-completion (because it doesn't pop up when typing the beginnings of 'projection')
 
* problem of capturing the 'overlaps with' aspect in addition to 'anterior to'
 
* full text search of the definitions would be very useful
 
 
Character #6
 
* hypural is also contained within the upper lobe of the caudal fin
 
* difficulty of finding and comparing definitions of relationship types
 
 
Character #7
 
* Software should ensure that entity starts with an entity term if post-composed, not a quality
 
 
Character #8
 
* sphenotic needs to go into the comment field
 
 
Character #9
 
* too complex to express the exact nature of the orientation, so choose just 'orientation'
 
 
Character #10
 
* triradiate versus tripartite
 
  
 
[[Category:Data Jamboree 2]]
 
[[Category:Data Jamboree 2]]
 
[[Category:Curation]]
 
[[Category:Curation]]

Revision as of 15:43, 7 October 2008